Older Americans Face New Taxes on Catch Up 401(k) Contributions

Older Americans Face New Taxes on Catch Up 401(k) Contributions

A major shift in retirement savings rules is changing how many older Americans fund their 401(k) plans, making tax planning increasingly important for higher earners who could face a higher tax bill.

Beginning 01-01-2026, a federal rule requires many workers age 50 and older who earn above a set threshold to make their catch-up 401(k) contributions on a Roth basis. That means the extra money must be contributed after tax, rather than before, eliminating a long-standing deduction that has been especially valuable during peak earning years.

It is going to materially affect this group of people, said Matthew Petersen, executive director of the National Association of Government Defined Contribution Administrators. Yet many employees remain unaware that the change is already in effect.

Some employers automatically shift affected workers into Roth catch-up contributions. Others require employees to actively approve the switch. Those who miss the notice risk losing the ability to make catch-up contributions altogether.

Here is what every older worker should know.

What are catch-up contributions

The IRS allows workers age 50 and older to save more in their 401 (k) plans, helping strengthen retirement balances late in their careers.

For 2026, the limits are as follows.

  • •The regular 401(k) contribution limit for all workers is $24,500.
  • •The catch-up contribution for individuals age 50 and older is $8,000.
  • •The enhanced catch-up for ages 60 to 63 is $11,250.

These limits also apply to 403 (b) and government 457 (b) plans. The Roth requirement does not apply to IRAs.

Who must use Roth for catch-up contributions

Starting in 2026, the Roth mandate applies to workers age 50 and older who earned more than $150,000 in the prior year from the same employer, including retirement contributions.

The income test is based on your prior year’s wages with your current employer. Because of that, a high earner hired in 2026 would generally still be allowed to make pretax catch-up contributions during 2026 since there were no wages from that employer in 2025 to trigger the rule. However, if that worker earns more than $ 150,000 in 2026, the Roth requirement would apply in 2027, when those wages become the look-back year.

Self-employed individuals are exempt because they do not receive W-2 wages from an employer.

How taxation changes under the new rule

Under the traditional 401 (k) structure, contributions reduce taxable income today, and withdrawals are taxed in retirement. Many workers expect to be in a lower tax bracket later, which makes pretax savings particularly attractive during high-earning years.

Roth contributions reverse that timing. Taxes are paid now, but qualified withdrawals in retirement are tax-free. Roth accounts can also help retirees manage income in years when higher withdrawals could trigger Medicare premium surcharges or higher marginal tax rates.

Most large employers now offer both traditional and Roth options. For affected high earners, the difference is simple. The catch-up portion must go into the Roth bucket.

What to do if you are subject to the Roth mandate

Your next steps depend on how your employer’s plan is structured.

Some plans automatically convert catch-up contributions to Roth for workers who meet the income threshold. Others require written consent before making the change. If consent is not provided, catch-up contributions may be suspended.

Workers should contact their plan administrator immediately to confirm whether they must take action to avoid losing their catch-up contributions under the new Roth requirement.

Among plans administered by Vanguard, about two-thirds require higher earners to actively approve Roth catch-ups. By contrast, most Fidelity-administered plans are automating the switch.

Fidelity Angela Capek says some employers prefer an active election so participants clearly understand the impact on take-home pay and long-term strategy. Either way, she recommends monitoring contributions closely to be sure catch-ups are going where intended.

If your plan automates the Roth switch, but you prefer not to make Roth catch-up contributions, monitor your pretax deferrals carefully and reduce them to $0 as you approach the $24,500 regular contribution limit for 2026.

What if your employer does not offer a Roth 401(k)

High earners in plans without a Roth feature will not be allowed to make catch-up contributions.

Among Vanguard-administered plans, 86 percent offered a Roth option in 2024, up from 74 percent in 2020. Still, that leaves a meaningful number of workers at risk of losing access to catch-up savings.

Should you stop making catch-up contributions to avoid Roth taxes

At a minimum, workers should understand the tradeoffs.

Consider a 60-year-old in the 35 percent tax bracket. Contributing the full $11,250 catch-up to a traditional 401(k) would reduce taxable income by that amount, saving nearly $4,000 in federal taxes. Making the same contribution to a Roth would increase adjusted gross income, which could limit other tax benefits or push the worker into a higher bracket.

If the choice is between making Roth catch-up contributions or making none at all, most workers are better off choosing the Roth option, especially if the goal is to maximize total retirement savings. While paying tax up front can feel painful, the long-term benefits of tax-free withdrawals and protection against future tax rate increases often outweigh the short-term cost. For many higher earners, funding a Roth today can serve as an effective hedge against higher taxes later in retirement.

That said, Roth accounts offer two powerful advantages. Withdrawals are tax-free, and Roth 401 (k) balances are not subject to required minimum distributions during the owner’s lifetime.

Why is this change happening

The Roth catch-up requirement stems from legislation passed by Congress in 2022. One of its purposes is to generate near-term tax revenue to help offset the cost of other retirement-related reforms in the law.

For workers nearing retirement, the message is clear. The rules changed in 2026, and the sooner you understand how those changes affect your paycheck, your taxes, and your future income, the better positioned you will be to make smart decisions in your final years of saving.

Please contact our office at 516-482-7777 for a complete review of your tax strategy.

Comments are closed.